Budgeting apps you buy once instead of subscribing
A budget is a tool for spending less. Paying a yearly subscription for one is an awkward place to start, and it is the complaint underneath a great many of the angry reviews of the well-known budgeting apps. Here is what the subscription is actually paying for, and when a one-time purchase is the better deal.
What the subscription pays for
Three things, mostly: the bank-sync data provider, which charges per connected account every month; the servers that hold your budget; and continuous development. That is a real cost and a defensible model — as long as you are getting all three. If the bank connection does not work in your country, you are paying the ongoing cost of a service you are not receiving, and the app on your screen is doing a job a spreadsheet could do offline.
What a one-time purchase can and cannot include
A one-off payment works when the software does not have a per-user running cost. An app that keeps your budget on your own machine has almost none: no per-account data fees, no storage, no sync servers. What a one-off cannot honestly promise is unlimited future work for free. The fair version is what it says on the tin: you buy the app, you keep the app, and later versions of the same app are included — not a promise that somebody will maintain it forever at their own expense. Be suspicious of the opposite trick too: a one-time purchase that turns out to unlock a crippled version, with the useful part behind a second payment.
Questions worth asking before you pay anything
· Does the free version actually work, or is it a demo shaped like a product? · If you stop paying, do you keep your data in a form you can use? · Is the price per person or per household? · Does the app need an account at all, and if so, why? · What happens to the budget if the company disappears? An app that keeps a plain file on your own disk answers the last two comfortably. An app that keeps your budget on a server has to be trusted for both.
Where handbudget sits
The browser edition is free, permanently, and it is the whole app — envelopes, transactions, months, import and export. It is not a trial and nothing is held back to make the paid version look better. The desktop edition is a single payment for a native app on Windows and Linux, including later versions. There is no per-seat pricing: one household, one payment. That is possible only because handbudget has no bank connections and no servers holding budgets — there is no monthly cost to pass on to you.
Frequently asked questions
Is a free budgeting app going to sell my data?
It is the right question to ask of any free product. handbudget's browser edition never sends your budget anywhere — it is stored in your browser, and there is no account, so there is nothing to sell or to lose in a breach.
What do I get for the one-time payment?
The desktop app for Windows and Linux, which keeps your budget as a plain file on your own disk and works with no internet connection at all — and every later version of it.
Will the price turn into a subscription later?
No. A purchase already made stays a purchase. If a future product ever needed a running cost behind it, that would be a different product with its own price, not a change to this one.
More guides
Other things we made
Also in English, made by the same people.
Also in English, made by the same people.
Also in English, made by the same people.
Also in English, made by the same people.